Who Is To Blame In Cincinnati?

“Who Dey” Nation Wants Answers

There’s been much speculation throughout the blogosphere regarding who exactly is to blame for the colossal failure that has been the first seven games of the 2010 Bengals campaign.  Joe Reedy at Cincinnati.com, Hobson at Bengals.com, our friends at Cincy Jungle, and the various discussion boards have taken up this topic and chewed over it at length over the last several days.

Some say the fault lies with Marvin Lewis.  After all, he’s the head coach—he calls the shots.  He admitted to calling the third-down pass play that led directly to Tampa Bay’s comeback win.  If the Bengals win that game, (which was in the bag) who knows where they’d be now?  The roster is supposedly stacked with talent, so it must be Marvin’s fault.  Anyone seen any “In Marvin We Trust” T-shirts lately?  Me neither.

Others point to Bob Bratkowski and his sometimes overly-predictable and other times ridiculously bone-headed play calling.  He was the favorite whipping boy in Bengaldom last year, and frankly he’s done nothing to change perceptions in 2010. I freely admit I was so sick of “Brat” that I openly lobbied for Mike Martz to be hired in Cincinnati.  Some say the offense is too complicated, leading to penalties and missed assignments.  Others say it’s the same thing that’s been run since 2005 and everyone in the stadium knows what the next play is.  Either way, despite a supposedly Pro Bowl caliber QB and two superstar WR’s, not to mention two top draft picks and a former first round running back, this offense struggles mightily.

Then there’s the defense.  Less than six months since Mike Zimmer was canonized in Cincinnati as a conquering hero, his charges have failed to repeat 2009’s successes despite having the same starters and better depth.  They have shown inconsistency in run defense, and the pass rush has been non-existent—even when blitzing. What’s worse, they couldn’t get a stop when they knew the opposing offense was going to run to try to close out the game twice (Cleveland and Miami).  Those failures allowed the opponent to run out the last two minutes and deny the offense one last gasp.

How about Carson Palmer?  While flashing some brilliance at times this year, large chunks of the season have looked a lot like 2009 when he was absolutely putrid at critical moments.  He looks to have lost zip on his passes, and could have about 7 or 8 more interceptions this year if not for the stone hands of opposing DB’s.  Whether you count yourself as pro- or anti-Palmer, no one can argue that he’s just not the same guy he was in 2005 and 2006.

And when all else fails, blame Mike Brown.  After all, he’s the man at the top and ultimately responsible for two decades of consistent failure. Restart the “Mike Brown, Step Down” campaign!  Look for mikebrownsucks.com to get restarted.

As for me, the official position of Bengals Gab is the blame lies in something more vague and ambiguous.  It has nothing to do with 40-yard dash times, playbook schemes, or simple blocking and tackling.  If it were something like that, it would easily be fixed.

No, the problem with the 2010 Cincinnati Bengals is something much more difficult to get a handle on.

Looking at the roster, this team should be able to compete with anyone in the league.  The offense is stacked.  The defense too.  A team that won the division last year and swept every home-and-home got only more talented in the offseason.  The coaching staff enjoyed another year of relative stability, and the Bengals spent freely—almost recklessly—in free agency to improve the roster. They did well with their nine draft picks, and had the advantage of an extra preseason game.

So what went wrong here?

I humbly submit that the problem with this team is simply a lack of heart.

I stated back in the spring that this team would have no excuses, and I still don’t see any.  They have simply failed to deliver.  They’ve believed the hype surrounding them in the offseason, and become overly infatuated with the publicity and hoopla surrounding them.

They lost their focus and they lost their resolve.  They forgot what the whole point of this exercise is—to win a championship.  This is a lack of heart.

Heart, as defined by me, is a desire to succeed at all costs.  To put team success above personal notoriety, and to be focused on the end result in all endeavors.  This team does not do any of that.

They too often focus on why they “Can’t” instead of why they “Can.” In the immortal words of Yoda, I say to the Bengals, “That is why you fail.”

Cincinnati’s opponent Monday, Pittsburgh, didn’t spend the kind of money Mike Brown did in the spring.  They arguably didn’t draft as well. They were coming off a season in which they missed the playoffs, and they had the distraction of Ben Roethlisberger’s rape allegations and subsequent suspension.

They had problems in areas the Bengals did not.  They had obstacles to overcome that were non-existant in Cincinnati.

But they are 5-2, and the Bengals are 2-5 for one reason: They have heart.

If the Bengals were somehow able to transplant the heart and desire found in Pittsburgh or Baltimore—or Cleveland for that matter—and put it into the talent on this roster, the Bengals could go 9-0 down the stretch and make the playoffs.

How do you coach that?  How do you instill such a thing in your players?  I don’t know.  And neither does Marvin Lewis.

Maybe Mike Tomlin and Eric Mangini know a thing or two this staff doesn’t.  Maybe its more a, “you have it or you don’t” kind of thing.  I don’t know.

All I do know is that as long as the Bengals continue to search for “answers” in the tape, and talk to each other about better execution and being more “on the same page”, the more they will struggle.  Once they rightfully call B.S. on all of that hogwash and simply “Do Your Job” as Lewis once espoused, they can salvage something meaningful from this dreadful abortion of a season.

Who is to blame?  EVERYBODY.

Just my two cents.  I could be wrong.


Enjoyed this post?
Subscribe to NFL Gridiron Gab via RSS Feed or E-mail and receive daily news updates from us!

Submit to Digg  Stumble This Story  Share on Twitter  Post on Facebook  Post on MySpace  Add to del.icio.us  Bark It Up  Submit to Reddit  Fave on Technorati

3 Responses to “Who Is To Blame In Cincinnati?”

  1. John says:

    Lack of playmakers and poor coaching. Last year the team won on emotion. Two deaths and two early last minute comebacks cemented the resolve of the team. When they met teams with as much talent, they folded.

    Here’s what they lack:

    Linebackers. Jones is smart but smarts can only take you so far. Rivers is fragile and just not a superstar. The Soamoan is plain dumb. Johnson is their most versatile backer, but doesn’t start.

    Pass rushers. Can’t anyone here rush the passer? Anyone? The DEs probably would not start for anyone else. Outside of Peko, there isn’t a good DT on the roster. Tank is okay but hurt a lot; Sims is dumb (although how smart do you have to be to play DT?).

    Guard. Williams is old but serviceable. Outside of that, there isn’t anyone who would start for anyone else.

    Coaching. Lewis has game time management flaws. He also can’t make halftime adjustments–or anytime adjustments. Brats offense is predictable. No pass rush means that maybe Hayes should be evaluated.

    Fix: Zimmer as HC. Marvin as GM. Fitz as DC. Martz as OC.

  2. Kmach says:

    #1 Bob Bratkowski and #2 Marv Lewis. Watching the Bengals predictable offense is mindnumbing. There is too much pressure on Palmer to convert 3rd and long against the opponents passing unit. If I am bored to tears watching the Bengals offense I can’t imagine what the players are going through. With big and imaginative plays comes emotion, excitement, and motivated players. Cincinnati needs to bring someone in who can create a more dynamic and exciting offense.

    Marv Lewis’ contract expires this year and I say he has had his chance. Bring in a big name head coach to instill some confidence in the players. While I think the players like Lewis, I don’t necessarily believe they are 100% confident in his ability to create a championship calibur team.

  3. BMN says:

    Mike Brown: won 100 games slower than any owner in NFL history and, as of late night, lost 200 games FASTER than any owner in NFL history.

    The problems all start there and no problems after that matter until that problem is resolved.